The Art of Collecting: Navigating the Art Market — Part II

What are some of the most common mistakes new collectors make, and how do you guide them past these pitfalls?

The most common mistake is not starting soon enough!

A lot of people waste time simply because they don't know where to begin. They feel overwhelmed by the abundance of artistic movements, genres and works available online and beyond, or discouraged by the perceived cost of entering the collecting world.

But the reality is that there is compelling art to be discovered across a wide range of budgets. If someone feels uncertain about their own judgement, involving a professional art advisor can help them navigate the intricacies of the market with greater confidence.

Another common mistake I encounter when working with new clients is overpaying at auction or on the secondary market. Without reliable reference points for assessing fair market value, enthusiastic collectors can sometimes do themselves a disservice by paying considerably more than a work warrants.

Condition is another frequently overlooked consideration. Restoration, provenance, exhibition history and previous auction appearances can all materially influence a work's desirability and value.

There are so many nuances involved, which is precisely why seeking professional advice before making a significant acquisition can be invaluable.

How do you discover and evaluate artists for your clients? What qualities do you look for in their work and career trajectories?

I look for an instantly recognisable visual language and a unique artistic point of view. It should feel like an aha! moment: you see a work and immediately know, "That's them!"

Think about Mark Rothko, Helen Frankenthaler or Joan Mitchell. Their artistic languages are unmistakable. Among contemporary artists, consider Julie Mehretu, George Condo, Tracey Emin or James Turrell. It is difficult to confuse their work with anybody else's.

Those are rather obvious examples, of course, but sometimes it comes down to the tiniest detail. Take the signature red nail polish on Danielle McKinney's heroines. You recognise the artist almost instantly.

Then comes institutional support, which helps secure an artist's longevity beyond fleeting market tastes. Trends come and go, as the post-pandemic speculative bubble surrounding ultra-contemporary art demonstrated rather spectacularly. Museum recognition, meaningful exhibitions and strong gallery representation are crucial to establishing an artist's lasting significance. I also pay close attention to the important private collections in which an artist's work is represented. Certain collectors have historically been remarkably perceptive in identifying artistic talent, and their collections can serve as useful bellwethers of contemporary taste.

Ultimately, I am interested in artists whose practices possess both aesthetic distinction and the depth to sustain serious critical engagement over time.

What role do auction houses, art fairs and blue-chip galleries play in your collection-building strategy?

Auction houses provide the most accessible public record of transactional prices, offering valuable insight into demand, liquidity and the market's appetite for particular artists. I monitor auction data when evaluating gallery pricing and, on occasion, can secure considerably better terms at auction than through private secondary-market transactions. Art fairs, meanwhile, are a wonderful way to accelerate the process of discovering art and meeting galleries from around the world, all within a matter of hours.

Of course, for me, they involve weeks of scouring PDFs, researching presentations and arranging appointments beforehand. My clients get to enjoy the guided tours afterwards! Overall, I find art fairs tremendous fun, and they are often very productive occasions for acquisitions. Blue-chip galleries are indispensable sources of primary-market material, although dealing with them can sometimes be rather frustrating.

The practice of so-called BOGO arrangements, where collectors are expected to acquire or donate an additional work in exchange for access to a particularly sought-after artist, has been extensively debated. Yet sometimes, even securing the opportunity to enter such an arrangement can be challenging! Allocation decisions can repeatedly favour a select group of established collectors. This is where an art advisor's relationships and reputation become particularly valuable, especially when helping newer collectors gain access to works that might otherwise remain out of reach.

Ultimately, auction houses, galleries and art fairs form an interconnected market ecosystem. Understanding the strengths, limitations and dynamics of each is essential to using them to a client's advantage.

What role does provenance play in your decision-making, and how do you approach authentication and due diligence?

Provenance can make or break an artwork's value. If a work once belonged to a celebrated collector, historical figure or cultural icon, that association can command a substantial premium. The same applies to works originating from distinguished single-owner collections. Consider the Paul G. Allen and Macklowe sales, where exceptional provenance contributed to extraordinary market interest.

Conversely, gaps in a work's ownership history, frequent changes of hands or repeated auction appearances can raise questions and diminish its desirability. A history of being bought in at auction, meaning offered but left unsold, can also affect market perception.

Provenance is equally important for authentication. A clear and well-documented chain of ownership provides greater confidence, while exhibition histories, scholarly references and inclusion in catalogues raisonnés can further substantiate a work's attribution.

Condition is another essential part of due diligence. I believe in being very hands-on, including examining works under ultraviolet light to identify potential restoration or later interventions. Naturally, more complex questions require specialist conservators and authentication experts. Even seemingly minor issues can have significant implications for a work's future value, so there is no substitute for thorough research and careful examination.

How has the profile of the collector changed in recent years? Are you seeing different motivations, priorities or expectations among those entering the market today?

I have never liked to generalise, but one thing is certain: there are considerably fewer speculators entering the market in the hope of making a quick flip. Since the art market slowed following its pandemic-era highs, flipping ultra-contemporary works for an immediate profit has become virtually impossible in many segments. Nowadays, I tend to encounter either passionate collectors, who have no intention of selling within their lifetimes, or serious investors approaching acquisitions with a long-term mindset, prepared to hold works for decades.

Quite often, these two profiles are not mutually exclusive. They coexist within the same collector: someone who wants to make financially sound acquisitions with the potential to appreciate over time, while surrounding themselves with art they genuinely enjoy living with. Another particularly interesting development among my clients is the growing ambition to establish private museums and share their collections with a wider public. For some, collecting is evolving beyond private ownership into a form of cultural patronage. There is a desire not merely to possess significant works, but to create something enduring around them.

We often hear about a "buyer's market", but what does that actually look like behind the scenes? Has the shift in negotiating power materially changed your conversations with galleries, auction houses and sellers?

In practical terms, a buyer's market means I can negotiate more favourable acquisition terms for my clients. Just as importantly, it gives them a little more time to make informed decisions. During the more heated periods, discounts were practically unheard of, and you often had to make a decision the minute a PDF landed in your inbox. Otherwise, the work would be gone! The current environment allows for a more measured approach, which I consider considerably healthier. There is greater scope for research, due diligence and thoughtful negotiation, rather than simply reacting to artificial urgency.

Of course, exceptions exist. Even in a buyer's market, certain artists maintain lengthy waiting lists, and the scarcity of available primary-market works can create a frenzy whenever a new exhibition is announced. Think Christine Ay Tjoe or Danielle McKinney. So while the broader market may have become more accommodating, access to the most coveted works remains highly competitive.

Has the slower market changed what constitutes a good opportunity? Are there artists, periods or segments that collectors can approach differently today than they could three or four years ago?

Absolutely! Today, there is simply no need to rush into acquiring works by the majority of emerging and ultra-contemporary market darlings. A few years ago, collectors were often operating under considerable pressure, with rapidly escalating prices and very little time to assess whether an artist's market momentum was sustainable.

Now, there is an opportunity to approach this segment far more thoughtfully and deliberately. Collectors have time to study an artist's practice, evaluate the quality of individual works and consider whether an acquisition genuinely belongs in their collection. I find that particularly encouraging. A slower market allows connoisseurship and careful judgement to take precedence over speculation.

And who knows? You might even be lucky enough to negotiate a studio visit. Always worth trying!

What do headlines about a cooling art market get wrong about what is actually happening on the ground?

Everything! Well, almost everything. The headlines can be terribly dramatic and clickbait-driven. Life ebbs and flows, and the art market is no exception. What we are witnessing is not the disappearance of collecting, but a change in market dynamics. Certain emerging artists, whose prices were driven to extraordinary heights without necessarily having the artistic or institutional foundations to justify them, have experienced significant corrections. The speculative flipping culture has largely evaporated, and quality, provenance and artistic significance are once again taking precedence.

Let's be honest, some of those artists were hyped beyond all reasonable merit!

The broader economic environment has also changed. Capital is no longer as inexpensive as it was during the era of exceptionally low interest rates, so collectors are taking more time before pulling the trigger. Personally, I don't think that is a bad thing. Serious collectors are still buying, and new collectors continue to enter the market, even if not quite en masse as some in the art world might have hoped.

There are also important structural changes underway. We are in the midst of an extraordinary intergenerational transfer of wealth, with substantial assets expected to pass from the Silent Generation and Baby Boomers to younger generations.

But here is the caveat: before much of that wealth reaches Millennials and Gen Z, it may first pass to surviving spouses. And because women tend to outlive their husbands — sorry, guys! — we could see a considerable increase in female-led collecting and patronage over the coming years. The bigger question, in my opinion, is how the art world can engage the newly minted millionaires and billionaires emerging from the artificial intelligence boom. This cohort has proved surprisingly elusive as a collecting audience so far, despite possessing considerable purchasing power.

Hauser & Wirth's expansion into Palo Alto is a particularly interesting development in this respect. Its success in cultivating relationships with Silicon Valley's wealth creators could serve as a bellwether for the wider art market.

Ultimately, I believe the market is undergoing a necessary recalibration, rather than some existential crisis. The emphasis is shifting back towards discernment, quality, and long-term conviction. And frankly, that is a much more interesting environment in which to collect.

Next
Next

The Art of Collecting: The Philosophy Behind Merveille Art Advisory — Part I